3
$\begingroup$

I am working on Decision Making in Self driving cars and I am wondering how I can use Neural networks (is there any type) ? that can repleace or mimic the bayesian networks or Decision Tree for Decision Making process ?

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I think you would have to provide a whole lot more detail. Something like a self-driving car uses a series of data science models, doing all kinds of specialized tasks, to keep driving. There is no "single" component (like a single decision tree) that you can just swap and replace with NN and have the whole thing work. $\endgroup$ – I_Play_With_Data Oct 19 '18 at 19:40
1
$\begingroup$

I would like more details regarding your actual problem, but here is my suggestion to apply artificial neural networks for decision making.

  • One way of approaching this problem is by using priori as one of the parameters for a deep neural network. This could be treated as similar as a classification problem with the basis of supervised learning.
  • The desired decisions and its parameters can be labelled and the output layer can have as many neurons as the desired number of decisions. Then series of training and validation can be conducted until the training reaches expected accuracy.

Best, Sangathamilan Ravichandran.

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

One of the central challenges to using neural networks for decision processes is the transparency of the decision mechanism. We tend to grant more trust and credence to algorithms that we can see some of the intermediate reasoning steps for.

Neural networks are, notoriously, black-boxes algorithms in which the intermediate steps are largely obscured from the developer and/or user.

To that end, using a method to explain the decision mechanism of the neural network such as lime or some proxy model approach, to express the decisions made by the network via an alternative model type such as decision trees or linear models, which lend themselves better to interpretation allows us to address this property of neural networks.

That said, there's no direct barrier to using neural networks as the basis of a decision system. Any function which takes data and outputs a prescriptive decision could meet this criterion.

The real trick is ensuring to yourself (as the developer of the algorithm) that the decisions the network is making are in line with the decisions you want it to make and, separately, building confidence through evidence to the stakeholders of the algorithm that:

  1. The engine is making the decisions they need it to
  2. That they have a sufficient understanding of how that decision is being made to trust it to make the decision correctly going forward
  3. That the mechanism the algorithm is using is "fair"-- in that it's not going to adversely affect one group or another in ways that could have serious ethical, regulatory, or legal consequences-- and other risks posed by the implementation of the alorithm for its intended purpose are expressed. This instance comes to mind as as a specific risk for self-driving car decisions. Self-driving cars have potentially huge benefits, but it would be irresponsible (at least) to ignore the ways the AI that powers them could go wrong.

It's worth saying that the last two points above are often not well-understood by stakeholders and therefore fall to the developer, as the person who should have the knowledge of risks related to the approach they are using, to proactively address.

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Great answer. The black box nature is indeed a concern and eliminates NN from some approaches (like credit decisions). As for the example you posted, I am personally bearish on self-driving cars (have been for a few years now). That uber accident was the first of its kind but far from the last. $\endgroup$ – I_Play_With_Data Oct 22 '18 at 13:28
  • $\begingroup$ @UnknownCoder Oh, for sure. I am also personally bearish on self-driving cars, but it's definitely worth noting that errors in the decision process of the algorithms of these autonomous vehicles can have costs that manifest themselves quite visibly. All of society quickly becomes the stakeholder group for AI of this kind, and the 3 sets of principles I've outlined in the answer are definitely applicable in the case of these vehicles. $\endgroup$ – Thomas Cleberg Oct 22 '18 at 13:41
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @UnknownCoder Based on your comment, also clarified the responsibilities of the developer in section 3. Thanks! $\endgroup$ – Thomas Cleberg Oct 22 '18 at 13:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.