Skip to main content
Ufuk Can Bicici's user avatar
Ufuk Can Bicici's user avatar
Ufuk Can Bicici's user avatar
Ufuk Can Bicici
  • Member for 6 years, 3 months
  • Last seen more than a month ago
awarded
comment
Would Deep Q Learning work for a finite horizon problem?
Yes, actually exactly that. I just thought about it since my policies are not stationary. At each time step I have a different policy distribution. In common applications the policies are stationary; you use the same policy network over and over for each time step. But anyway, your answers were really helpful for me, thank you very much!
comment
Would Deep Q Learning work for a finite horizon problem?
Would the following work then, based on the discussion so far; like in my previous comment: First optimizing $E[r_2]$ with respect to $\pi_2(a_2|s_2)$, using a vanilla policy gradient algorithm, without using actor critics or value functions and then optimizing $E[r_1 + V_2(s_2)]$ with respect to $\pi_1(a_1|s_1)$ by using the $V_2$ which we learn from the first optimization procedure. So there would be two separate neural networks for the two policies $\pi_1$ and $\pi_2$ in the end.
revised
Loading…
awarded
comment
Would Deep Q Learning work for a finite horizon problem?
Oh, so I see that Q learning assumptions are about an infinte horizon case. Would policy gradients help me then? I think it is possible to maximize $V_2(s)$ wrt $\pi_2$ and then using them, frozen, for maximizing $V_1(s)$ wrt $\pi_1, as proposed here: rll.berkeley.edu/deeprlcoursesp17/docs/lec1.pdf
comment
Would Deep Q Learning work for a finite horizon problem?
Many thanks for the detailed answer. Is the main problem in my case that the Bellman equation does not hold for me right? Is it only valid for problems with infinite time steps? I didn't exactly get what violates the Bellman equation in my case.
revised
Loading…
Loading…
comment
About the time differences in the Bellman equation
Thanks for the answer. Yes, basically we assume that we are in a Markovian system where all information we currently have depends just on the last step, we have a MDP. Sometimes I see some authors dropping time indices altogether when defining the Bellman Equality, so I wondered given common assumptions, is the value function stationary so we can work without the time index.
revised
Loading…
Loading…
awarded
comment
Are word embeddings further updated during training for document classification?
Thanks for the answer. So, we can safely assume that treating them as constant inputs is the usual practice, right?
revised
Loading…
awarded
revised
Loading…
awarded
awarded