4
$\begingroup$

In the BERT paper, I learnt that BERT is encoder-only model, that is it involves only transformer encoder blocks.

In the GPT paper, I learnt that GPT is decoder-only model, that is it involves only transformer decoder blocks.

I was guessing whats the difference. I know following difference between encoder and decoder blocks: GPT Decoder looks only at previously generated tokens and learns from them and not in right side tokens. BERT Encoder gives attention to tokens on both sides.

But I have following doubts:

Q1. GPT2,3 focuses on new/one/zero short learning. Cant we build new/one/zero short learning model with encoder-only architecture like BERT?

Q2. Huggingface Gpt2Model contains forward() method. I guess, feeding single data instance to this method is like doing one shot learning?

Q3. I have implemented neural network model which utilizes output from BertModel from hugging face. Can I simply swap BertModel class with GPT2Model with some class and will it. The return value of Gpt2Model.forward does indeed contain last_hidden_state similar to BertModel.forward. So, I guess swapping out BertModel with Gpt2Model will indeed work, right?

Q4. Apart from being decoder-only and encoder-only, auto-regressive vs non-auto-regressive and whether or not accepting tokens generated so far as input, what high level architectural / conceptual differences GPT and BERT have?

$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

3
$\begingroup$

To start with your last question: you correctly say that BERT is an encoder-only model trained with the masked language-modeling objective and operates non-autoregressively. GPT-2 is a decode-only model trained using the left-to-right language objective and operates autoregressively. Other than that, there are only technical differences in hyper-parameters, but no other conceptual differences.

BERT (other masked LMs) could also be used for zero- or few-shot learning, but in a slightly different way. There is a method called PET (Pattern- Exploiting Training). It uses the language modeling abilities of BERT via templates. E.g., for sentiment analysis, you can do something like:

<...text of the review..><.TEMPLATE......> <  ?  >.
The pizza was fantastic. The restaurant is [MASK].

Then you check what score was would good and bad get at the position of the [MASK] token.

Working with the GPT-2 model is not that straightforward as with BERT. Calling the forward method returns the hidden states of GPT-2 given the input you provided that can be further used in a model. You can use hidden states of GPT-2 as contextual embeddings, the same way that you the output of BERT, however, this is not how GPT-2 is usually used.

The usual way of using GPT-2 sampling from the model. This means that you provide a prompt (as plain text) and hope that the model will continue in a reasonable way. There are many tutorials on how to generate from the GPT-2 models, e.g., this blog post by Huggingface.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.